Understanding the Risks and Rewards of Uterine Transplantation: Review
Abstract
Uterus transplantation (UTx) studies have been delivered in several international locations, with trials in Sweden and the us generating successful consequences. The developing interest in developing UTx trials in different countries, consisting of Spain, the Netherlands, Japan, and Australia, raises essential questions concerning the ethics of surgical innovation research in the discipline of UTx. This paper examines the modern-day kingdom of UTx inside the context of the surgical innovation paradigm and perfect framework and discusses the ethical demanding situations faced by way of the ones considering the creation of recent trials. We argue that UTx remains an experimental technique at a notably early stage of the best framework, in particular in the context of de novo trials, where protocols are likely to deviate from those used previously and in which researchers are probably to have restrained revel in of UTx. We finish that international locations thinking about the creation of UTx trials should construct on the strengths of the said effects to consolidate the evidence base and shed mild on the uncertainties of the method. government answerable for the ethical governance of UTx trials are suggested to attract on the moral framework used in the oversight of surgical innovation.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
-Richards, Elliott G., et al. "Framing the diagnosis and treatment of absolute uterine factor infertility: insights from in-depth interviews with uterus transplant trial participants." AJOB empirical bioethics 10.1 (2019): 23-35.
-Ngaage, Ledibabari M., et al. "The changing paradigm of ethics in uterus transplantation: a systematic review." Transplant International 33.3 (2020): 260-269.
-Johnson, Jane, and Wendy Rogers. "Innovative surgery: the ethical challenges." Journal of Medical Ethics 38.1 (2012): 9-12.
-Johannesson, Liza, et al. "Guidelines for standardized nomenclature and reporting in uterus transplantation: an opinion from the United States Uterus Transplant Consortium." American Journal of Transplantation 20.12 (2020): 3319-3325.
-Johannesson, Liza, et al. "Dallas UtErus Transplant Study: early outcomes and complications of robot-assisted hysterectomy for living uterus donors." Transplantation 105.1 (2021): 225-230.
-Johannesson, Liza, et al. "Life underneath the VCA umbrella: perspectives from the US Uterus Transplant Consortium." American Journal of Transplantation 21.5 (2021): 1699-1704.
-Järvholm, Stina, et al. "Uterus transplantation: joys and frustrations of becoming a ‘complete’woman—a qualitative study regarding self-image in the 5-year period after transplantation." Human Reproduction 35.8 (2020): 1855-1863.
-Testa, G., E. C. Koon, and L. Johannesson. "Living donor uterus transplant and surrogacy: ethical analysis according to the principle of equipoise." American Journal of Transplantation 17.4 (2017): 912-916.
-Riggan, Kirsten A., et al. "Provider knowledge and support of uterus transplantation: Surveying multidisciplinary team members." Mayo Clinic Proceedings: Innovations, Quality & Outcomes 4.2 (2020): 150-158.
-Brännström, Mats, Michael A. Belfort, and Jean Marc Ayoubi. "Uterus transplantation worldwide: clinical activities and outcomes." Current opinion in organ transplantation 26.6 (2021): 616-626.
-Testa, Giuliano, et al. "The evolution of transplantation from saving lives to fertility treatment: DUETS (Dallas UtErus Transplant Study)." Annals of Surgery 272.3 (2020): 411-417.
- Jones, Benjamin P., et al. "Uterine transplantation: scientific impact paper No. 65 April 2021." BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology 128.10 (2021): e51-e66.
- Brännström, Mats, Niclas Kvarnström, and Pernilla Dahm-Kähler. "Novel approaches in uterus transplantation." Current Opinion in Organ Transplantation 25.6 (2020): 584-593.
- Brännström, Mats, et al. "Outcome of recipient surgery and 6-month follow-up of the Swedish live donor robotic uterus transplantation trial." Journal of Clinical Medicine 9.8 (2020): 2338.
- Brännström, Mats, Niclas Kvarnström, and Pernilla Dahm-Kähler. "Novel approaches in uterus transplantation." Current Opinion in Organ Transplantation 25.6 (2020): 584-593.
- da Graca, Briget, et al. "Uterus transplantation: ethical considerations." Current Opinion in Organ Transplantation 26.6 (2021): 664-668.
-Kristek, Jakub, et al. "Limited availability of deceased uterus donors: a transatlantic perspective." Transplantation 103.12 (2019): 2449-2452.
-Chmel, Roman, et al. "Revaluation and lessons learned from the first 9 cases of a Czech uterus transplantation trial: Four deceased donor and 5 living donor uterus transplantations." American Journal of Transplantation 19.3 (2019): 855-864.
- Brännström, Mats, et al. "Global results of human uterus transplantation and strategies for pre-transplantation screening of donors." Fertility and Sterility 112.1 (2019): 3-10.
-Farrell, Ruth M., et al. "Evolving ethical issues with advances in uterus transplantation." American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 222.6 (2020): 584-e1.
-Flyckt, Rebecca, et al. "Uterine transplantation: surgical innovation in the treatment of uterine factor infertility." Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada 40.1 (2018): 86-93.
-Bruno, Bethany, and Kavita Shah Arora. "Ethical implications of donor type for uterus transplantation: why we should remain wary of using living donors." The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 93.4 (2020): 587.
-Kisu, Iori, et al. "Concerns associated with uterus transplantation in Japan." The Keio Journal of Medicine 70.3 (2020): 68-71.
-Carmona, Francisco, et al. "Uterine transplantation. First viable case in Southern Europe." Medicina Clínica (English Edition) 156.6 (2021): 297-300.
-Peters, H. E., et al. "Feasibility study for performing uterus transplantation in the Netherlands." Human reproduction open 2020.2 (2020): hoz032.
-Balayla, Jacques. "Uterine transplants in the Canadian setting: a theoretical framework." Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Canada 38.10 (2016): 955-960.
-Williams, Nicola. "Should deceased donation be morally preferred in uterine transplantation trials?." Bioethics 30.6 (2016): 415-424.
-Hammond-Browning, Natasha, and Nicola Jane Williams. "Developing an international registry for uterus transplantation (IRUTx): promises and challenges." Human Reproduction 35.12 (2020): 2643-2649.
-Daolio, Jessica, et al. "Uterine transplantation and IVF for congenital or acquired uterine factor infertility: a systematic review of safety and efficacy outcomes in the first 52 recipients." PLoS One 15.4 (2020): e0232323.
-O’Donovan, Laura, Nicola Jane Williams, and Stephen Wilkinson. "Ethical and policy issues raised by uterus transplants." British medical bulletin 131.1 (2019): 19-28.
-Fageeh, Wafa, et al. "Transplantation of the human uterus." International journal of gynecology & obstetrics 76.3 (2002): 245-251.
-Brännström, Mats, et al. "Livebirth after uterus transplantation." The Lancet 385.9968 (2015): 607-616.
-York, Jackie R., et al. "Neonatal outcomes after uterus transplantation: Dallas uterus transplant study." American Journal of Perinatology 40.01 (2023): 042-050.
-Ricci, Stephanie, Carrie Bennett, and Tommaso Falcone. "Uterine transplantation: evolving data, success, and clinical importance." Journal of Minimally Invasive Gynecology 28.3 (2021): 502-512.
-Richards, Elliott G., et al. "Framing the diagnosis and treatment of absolute uterine factor infertility: insights from in-depth interviews with uterus transplant trial participants." AJOB empirical bioethics 10.1 (2019): 23-35.
-Dahm-Kähler, Pernilla, Niclas Kvarnström, and Mats Brännström. "Robotic live donor hysterectomy." Current Opinion in Organ Transplantation 26.6 (2021): 640-645.
-El-Akouri, R. Racho, et al. "Heterotopic uterine transplantation by vascular anastomosis in the mouse." Journal of Endocrinology 174.2 (2002): 157-166.
-Brännström, Mats, et al. "Uterus transplantation: from research, through human trials and into the future." Human Reproduction Update 29.5 (2023): 521-544.
-Fronek, Jiri, et al. "Human uterus transplantation from living and deceased donors: the interim results of the first 10 cases of the Czech trial." Journal of Clinical Medicine 10.4 (2021): 586.
- Brännström, Mats, et al. "Evolution of surgical steps in robotics-assisted donor surgery for uterus transplantation: results of the eight cases in the Swedish trial." Fertility and Sterility 114.5 (2020): 1097-1107.
- Brännström, Mats, et al. "Reproductive, obstetric, and long-term health outcome after uterus transplantation: results of the first clinical trial." Fertility and Sterility 118.3 (2022): 576-585.
- Raziel, A., et al. "Surrogate in vitro fertilization outcome in typical and atypical forms of Mayer–Rokitansky–Küster–Hauser syndrome." Human Reproduction 27.1 (2012): 126-130.
-Glazier, Alexandra K. "Regulatory oversight in the United States of vascularized composite allografts." Transplant International 29.6 (2016): 682-685.
-Fonouni, Hamidreza, et al. "Comparison of the laparoscopic versus open live donor nephrectomy: an overview of surgical complications and outcome." Langenbeck's archives of surgery 399.5 (2014): 543-551.
-Broekman, Marike L., Michelle E. Carrière, and Annelien L. Bredenoord. "Surgical innovation: the ethical agenda: a systematic review." Medicine 95.25 (2016): e3790.
-Ceelen, Wim P. "Clinical research in surgery: threats and opportunities." European Surgical Research 53.1-4 (2014): 95-107.
-Reitsma, Angelique M., and Jonathan D. Moreno. "Ethical guidelines for innovative surgery." (2006).
-Biffl, Walter L., et al. "Responsible development and application of surgical innovations: a position statement of the Society of University Surgeons." Journal of the American College of Surgeons 206.6 (2008): 1204-1209.
-McKneally, Martin F. "Ethical problems in surgery: innovation leading to unforeseen complications." World journal of surgery 23.8 (1999): 786-788.
-Morreim, Haavi, Michael J. Mack, and Robert M. Sade. "Surgical innovation: too risky to remain unregulated?." The Annals of thoracic surgery 82.6 (2006): 1957-1965.
-Johnson, Jane, and Wendy Rogers. "Innovative surgery: the ethical challenges." Journal of Medical Ethics 38.1 (2012): 9-12.
-Karpowicz, Lila, Emily Bell, and Eric Racine. "Ethics oversight mechanisms for surgical innovation: a systematic and comparative review of arguments." Journal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics 11.2 (2016): 135-164.
-Chmel, Roman, et al. "Revaluation and lessons learned from the first 9 cases of a Czech uterus transplantation trial: Four deceased donor and 5 living donor uterus transplantations." American Journal of Transplantation 19.3 (2019): 855-864.
-Farrell, Ruth M., et al. "Evolving ethical issues with advances in uterus transplantation." American journal of obstetrics and gynecology 222.6 (2020): 584-e1.
-Flyckt, Rebecca L., et al. "Deceased donor uterine transplantation: innovation and adaptation." Obstetrics & Gynecology 128.4 (2016): 837-842.
-Petrini, Carlo, et al. "Ethical issues in uterine transplantation: psychological implications and informed consent." Transplantation Proceedings. Vol. 49. No. 4. Elsevier, 2017.
-Saso, Srdjan, et al. "Psychological assessment tool for patients diagnosed with absolute uterine factor infertility and planning to undergo uterine transplantation." Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology 34.6 (2014): 504-507.
-Elliott, Carl. "Doing harm: living organ donors, clinical research and The Tenth Man." Journal of medical ethics 21.2 (1995): 91-96.
-Abdeldayem, Hesham, et al. "Analysis of donor motivations in living donor liver transplantation." Frontiers in surgery 1 (2014): 25.
-Valapour, M., et al. "Assessing elements of informed consent among living donors." Clinical transplantation 25.2 (2011): 185-190.
-Caplan, Arthur L., et al. "Moving the womb." Hastings Center Report (2007): 18-20.3. Brännström M, Johannesson L, Bokström H, Kvarnström N, MölneJ, Dahm-Kähler P, et al. Livebirth after uterus transplantation.
Lancet. 2015;14:607–16.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.52155/ijpsat.v56.1.7891
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2026 Maged Naser

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

















